Mr. Smarty Man

Hollywood Prediction

Sam Raimi vs. Gore Verbinski

Sam Raimi and Gore Verbinski in an epic showdown! Whose directing career is more successful?

April 28, 2011

By Scott Croco

Sam Raimi  vs.  Gore Verbinski

Sam Raimi and Gore Verbinski are mostly known for their franchises (Evil Dead, Spider-Man, Pirates of the Caribbean), and their last names both end in "i". But who has had the more successful directing career so far?

 

Sam Raimi Gore Verbinski
12 # Films 8
Spider-Man (2002)
Spider-Man 2 (2004)
Hits Pirates of the Caribbean (2003)
Pirates of the Caribbean 2 (2006)
Flops Mousehunt (1997)
Evil Dead II (1987)
A Simple Plan (1998)
Spider-Man 3 (2007)
Notable The Ring (1987)
Pirates of the Caribbean 3 (2007)
Rango (2011)

 

Commercial Success Score is based on adjusted box office numbers, calculated using domestic box office dollars, average ticket price in release year, U.S. population, and tickets purchased per capita.

Gore Verbinski leads in total adjusted box office and average adjusted box office, thanks to the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise ($1.1B). Sam Raimi has the Spider-Man franchise ($1.1B) under his belt, but he also has a few box office weaklings, like A Simple Plan and The Gift.

Edge: Gore Verbinski


Critical Success Score is based on critics' scores as aggregated on Rotten Tomatoes and user scores from IMDB.

Verbinski is no contest for Raimi in this category. Raimi's films, lead by Spider-Man 2 and A Simple Plan average higher than Verbinski's, lead by Rango and Pirates of the Caribbean.

Edge: Sam Raimi


Miscellaneous Score is based on Academy award nominations and wins, number of films directed, number of films written, Director's Guild nominations and wins, appearances on AFI lists, and inclusions in the National Film Registry.

All of Gore Verbinski's Oscar nominations come from the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, Sam Raimi garnered nominations for A Simple Plan (2 noms, 0 wins) and Spider-Man 2 (3 noms, 1 win). The AFI and NFR lists are Verbinski and Raimi free. Verbinski has written 1 of his 8 films, Raimi has written 6 of his 12, which gives him the edge in this category.

Edge: Sam Raimi


Final Verdict! Final showdown score is the sum of the three categories' scores.

Gore Verbinski, from inauspicious beginnings (Mousehunt), to horror meastro (The Ring), to pirate captain (Pirates of the Caribbean). Versus Sam Raimi, from independent origins (The Evil Dead), to classic cheeseball western (The Quick and the Dead), to franchise filmmaker (Spider-Man). Thanks to Raimi's critical success, he wins this battle.

Winner: Sam Raimi

Stats:
Director Score F Rtng CS BO* ABO* BOS AN AW W MS
Sam Raimi 39.97 12 72.8% 20.9 1430 119 14.0 7 1 6 5.0
Gore Verbinski 34.53 8 61.7% 12.2 1553 194 18.7 11 1 1 3.7
* In Millions of Adjusted Domestic Dollars
     

More Hollywood Showdowns

Ridley Scott vs. The Coen bros.
Ridley Scott vs. The Coen bros.
Who has had the more successful directing career?
Star Trek vs. Harry Potter
Star Trek vs. Harry Potter
Which franchise has been more successful?

Best Picture Predictions

Best Picture of 2007 Oscar Prediction
Best Picture of 2007 Oscar Prediction
Here's your Best Picture winner for the 2008 80th Academy Awards.
Best Picture of 2015 Oscar Prediction
Best Picture of 2015 Oscar Prediction
Updated! - Can MSM's formula accurately predict the 2016 88th Academy Awards Best Picture winner?