Mr. Smarty Man

Hollywood Prediction

Oliver Stone vs. Quentin Tarantino

Oliver Stone and Quentin Tarantino in an epic showdown! Whose directing career is more successful?

February 6, 2011

By Scott Croco

Oliver Stone  vs.  Quentin Tarantino

Oliver Stone is a long-established and sometimes controversial director. Quentin Tarantino is a celebrated retro-ist and sometimes visionary. Which one has been more successful in Hollywood?

 

Oliver Stone Quentin Tarantino
17 # Films 7
Platoon (1986)
Born on the Fourth of July (1989)
JFK (1991)
Hits Pulp Fiction (1994)
Inglourious Basterds (2009)
The Hand (1981)
Heaven & Earth (1993)
U Turn (1997)
Alexander (2004)
W. (2008)
Flops
Wall Street (1987) Notable Reservoir Dogs (1992)
Jackie Brown (1997)
Kill Bill (2003-04)

 

Commercial Success Score is based on adjusted box office numbers, calculated using domestic box office dollars, average ticket price in release year, U.S. population, and tickets purchased per capita.

Oliver Stone leads in total adjusted box office, headed by Platoon, JFK, and Any Given Sunday. Quentin Tarantino, on the strength of Pulp Fiction and Inglourious Basterds, has the edge in average adjusted box office. Stone's totals trump Tarantino's averages in this showdown.

Edge: Oliver Stone


Critical Success Score is based on critics' scores as aggregated on Rotten Tomatoes and user scores from IMDB.

Oliver Stone has some decently reviewed films like JFK and Platoon, but most of his films are middle of the road when it comes to critical acclaim, such as Any Given Sunday and World Trade Center. Quentin Tarantino's body of work is highly regarded by critics, led by Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs.

Edge: Quentin Tarantino


Miscellaneous Score is based on Academy award nominations and wins, number of films directed, number of films written, Director's Guild nominations and wins, appearances on AFI lists, and inclusions in the National Film Registry.

Thanks to Platoon (8 noms, 4 wins), Born on the Fourth of July (8 noms, 2 wins), and JFK (8 noms, 2 wins), Oliver Stone has a solid lead in Academy nominations and awards. Tarantino has some Academy awards success with Pulp Fiction (7 noms, 1 win), and Inglourious Basterds (8 noms, 1 win). Oliver Stone has 3 Director's Guild nominations and 2 wins, Tarantino has 2 nominations and 0 wins. Stone and Tarantino each have 1 film on the AFI lists, neither has an NFR film. Stone has directed 17 films and wrote 9 of them, Tarantino has directed 7 films and wrote all 7. Stone's awards and quantity of films put him over the top in this category.

Edge: Oliver Stone


Final Verdict! Final showdown score is the sum of the three categories' scores.

While Oliver Stone comes out ahead in 2 categories, it's not enough to overcome Quentin Tarantino's dominance with critics.

Winner: Quentin Tarantino

Stats:
Director Score F Rtng CS BO* ABO* BOS AN AW W MS
Oliver Stone 40.60 17 61.7% 12.2 1274 75 10.7 31 9 9 17.7
Quentin Tarantino 42.60 7 81.4% 27.6 545 78 5.8 16 2 7 9.2
* In Millions of Adjusted Domestic Dollars
     

More Hollywood Showdowns

Sam Raimi vs. Gore Verbinski
Sam Raimi vs. Gore Verbinski
Who has had the more successful directing career?
Jaws vs. Jurassic Park
Jaws vs. Jurassic Park
Which franchise has been more successful?

Best Picture Predictions

Best Picture of 2007 Oscar Prediction
Best Picture of 2007 Oscar Prediction
Here's your Best Picture winner for the 2008 80th Academy Awards.
Best Picture of 2015 Oscar Prediction
Best Picture of 2015 Oscar Prediction
Updated! - Can MSM's formula accurately predict the 2016 88th Academy Awards Best Picture winner?